Raw vs. Kibble What Vets Want Every Pet Parent to Know

You love your pet like family — so when it comes to what goes in their bowl, the pressure is real.

Should you go raw for that “ancestral diet” glow, or stick to trusted commercial kibble? Is one truly healthier than the other, or is it all clever marketing?

Veterinarians across the globe are weighing in, and this article dives deep into the facts, fears, and fads around pet nutrition — so you can make the best decision for your furry friend.
A raw diet typically consists of:
Raw muscle meatOrgan meat (like liver and kidney)Bones (raw, never cooked)Sometimes fruits, veggies, eggs, or dairy
Advocates often refer to it as the BARF diet — Biologically Appropriate Raw Food — aiming to mimic what dogs or cats would eat in the wild.
Supporters say it leads to:
Shinier coatsCleaner teethSmaller stoolsBetter energy and fewer allergies
But is it all benefits and no risks?
Commercial pet food — kibble, canned, or semi-moist — is:
Cooked and processed for safety and shelf lifeRegulated by national food safety bodies (like AAFCO or FSSAI)Nutritionally balanced with added vitamins, minerals, and preservativesMany vet-recommended brands undergo extensive research and feeding trials. But not all commercial food is created equal — some contain questionable fillers or artificial additives.
We spoke to vets and analyzed position statements from veterinary bodies like the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) and World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA). Here’s what they agree on:
Higher protein contentMore palatable for picky eatersFewer additives or preservativesHelps pets with specific allergies (if well managed)Bacterial contamination: Raw meat can harbor Salmonella, E. coli, Listeria — dangerous for pets and humans.Nutritional imbalances: Many DIY raw meals lack vital nutrients (like calcium or taurine).Bone injuries: Raw bones can still cause choking or intestinal blockages.Cost and complexity: Raw diets can be expensive and hard to prepare correctly every time.Nutritionally complete and balanced (when from reputable brands)Convenient and affordableShelf-stable — great for emergencies or travelBacked by feeding trials and decades of researchHeavily processedOften high in carbohydrates or fillersPotential for recalls or poor-quality control in cheap brandsWhat About Pet-Specific Needs?
Not all dogs or cats thrive on the same diet. You must consider:
Breed and sizeAge and activity levelExisting health conditions (diabetes, kidney issues, allergies)Some dogs with food sensitivities may benefit from raw or limited-ingredient diets, while others (especially senior pets) may need the support of commercial formulas tailored to their needs.
Consult a vet or board-certified pet nutritionistSource high-quality meat from safe suppliersSanitize preparation surfaces and handsAvoid raw feeding in households with kids, elderly, or immunocompromised membersFreeze meat to kill certain parasitesResearch the brand: Does it meet AAFCO standards?Avoid those with vague labels like “meat by-products” without clear sourcesRotate flavors/formulas occasionally to reduce long-term risks of dietary imbalanceSome pet parents choose a hybrid route — offering both commercial and raw/home-cooked food. This offers variety and fresh nutrients, but the same rules apply: balance is critical.

Don’t just eyeball proportions — it can throw off your pet’s calorie and nutrient intake.

We often project our own food beliefs onto our pets. If we eat organic, we want the same for them. If we avoid carbs, we scan labels for “grain-free.”

But cats and dogs aren’t tiny humans — their digestive systems and nutritional needs are entirely different.

Key Reminder: The healthiest pet isn’t the one on the most expensive or trendiest diet — it’s the one whose food supports their unique health, energy, and happiness.

Meera, Cat Mom from Delhi:

“I switched to raw after my cat had chronic IBS. It helped! But I worked closely with a vet and had her blood tested regularly.”

Jason, Dog Dad from Bengaluru:

“Kibble gets a bad rap, but my lab’s been on Royal Canin since day one — he’s 11 now and thriving.”
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the raw vs. commercial debate. Both can work — or fail — depending on how they’re executed.

If you're committed to raw, do it safely, with professional help. If you prefer kibble or canned, invest in a quality brand and understand your pet’s needs.

At the end of the day, the best diet is the one that keeps your pet healthy, happy, and by your side for as long as possible.

Explore the latest trends and tips in Health & Fitness, Travel, Life Hacks, Fashion & Beauty, and Relationships at Times Life!